North Somerset Logo

Trading Standards prosecution

Date: 22 Sep 2006

The proprietor of a block paving company has been ordered to pay fines and costs of £4300 following a prosecution brought by North Somerset Council's Trading Standards.

Michael John O' Brian is the sole owner of a block paving company which uses the trading names A1 Contractors, A1 West Paving and A1 Driveways and is known to operate in North Somerset, Bristol, and Weston-super-Mare.

In February 2006 one of Mr O'Brian's salesmen called uninvited at the home of a partially-sighted, elderly widow in Backwell. She agreed to have her drive block paved and signed a contract which did not comply with consumer protection rules. The following day she had changed her mind and phoned the company to cancel the contract. They refused to cancel the contract and turned up later that day and started digging up her drive. This was despite the fact that the consumer has the right to cancel in seven days if the initial contact at home was uninvited. In addition their contract document said in small print that she could cancel within seven days but being partially sighted she could not read the small print.

She contacted the Trading Standards Service for help. They sent officers to her property who ordered Mr O'Brian's employees to stop work. When questioned, these employees provided false information about who owned the company.

Mr O'Brian was later arrested and questioned about what had happened by Trading Standards.

The case was heard on Friday 15 September 2006 at North Somerset Magistrates Court. Mr O'Brian was fined £2500 for failing to provide required information on his contract including failing to provide cancellation information with sufficient prominence.

In addition he was fined £1000 for failing to include company ownership details on his contract. North Somerset Council was awarded £830 in legal costs.

Cllr Deborah Yamanaka, executive member for environment and Community said: "Consumers should take time to shop around and think before signing contracts with doorstep sellers. We will take action against any rogue firms who take advantage of North Somerset residents."

Consumers experiencing similar problems should contact Trading Standards and Consumer Direct on 08454 04 05 06.

ENDS

Note to news editors: Mr O'Brian gave his home address as being in Naas Lane, Quedgley, Gloucester. The business address is 14, Orchard Street, Bristol but land is also leased at Moorland Park, Hewish.

The Consumer Protection (Cancellation of Contracts concluded away from Business Premises) Regulations 1987 require that contracts made as a result of an uninvited call by a trader must be in writing and include certain information. In particular they require that the contract should inform the consumer in a prominent manner that they can cancel the contract within seven days. Small print at the bottom of a contract is not prominent. Failure to comply is an offence.

The Business Names Act 1985 requires that invoices should contain details of who owns the business. Failure to comply is an offence.

Consumer Direct works in partnership with the Trading Standards Service. The Consumer Direct call centre uses trained advisors to give consumer advice and also handles calls for the Trading Standards Service. North Somerset Council has representation on the managing board.